This thesis examines the legal implications of pushbacks at the European Union’s (EU) external borders through the lens of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), focusing particularly on the prohibition of torture and inhuman or degrading treatment under Article 3 and the principle of non-refoulement. Pushbacks refer to the summary removal of migrants without access to asylum procedures or individual assessments, practices that often expose individuals to serious harm and raise concerns under international human rights law.
Using the legal dogmatic method, the thesis analyses how the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) interprets and applies the principle of non-refoulement, especially in situations where individuals face a real risk of ill-treatment upon return. The study reveals that although the Court consistently upholds the absolute character of Article 3, it initially imposes a high evidentiary threshold on applicants. Many are unable to meet this threshold due to intentional state practices such as undocumented removals, denial of access, asylum procedures and evasion of jurisdiction before the burden of proof shifts to the state. The judgment in N.D and N.T v. Spain further complicates the legal perspective by tying protection against collective expulsion to the behaviour of the applicants which narrows the scope of procedural safeguards and reinforces structural inequality.
The analysis shows that ECtHR case law offers both protection and ambiguity. Although the Court has played a crucial role in defining state responsibilities, its inconsistent application of evidentiary standards and jurisdictional thresholds weaken the effectiveness of the non-refoulement principle. The protection guaranteed under the ECHR is at risk of becoming illusory if procedural barriers continue to weaken access to justice for those exposed to pushbacks.