Some academic journals question the position of the research article as the only format of publication. This chapter looks at the challenges and potentials of publishing alternative genres to the research article in peer reviewed journals. In doing so, we illuminate the underlying assumptions and norms in academic publishing. We specifically focus on the peer review process of a ‘practitioner reflection’ genre and the ways in which this genre is negotiated between authors and reviewers. Peer review in higher education is often enmeshed with power, authority, and hierarchy as it assumes an authoritative expert and depends on critique within a competitive framework. Feminist and decolonial scholars have increasingly argued the need to rethink some of these practices as traditional peer reviewing can be seen to be rooted in (west) Eurocentric normative practices of knowledge production. As illustrations of our thinking, we present an analysis of three manuscripts and their related reviews: a reflection by a design practitioner; a reflection on pedagogic practice in the form of a comic; and an artist’s autoethnographic reflection. We argue that in academic publishing, we need to ‘disrupt’ established forms in order to push the boundaries of research genres. This can go some way towards the decolonization of knowledge-making systems in academia.