This study examines how political leaders of Sweden’s two biggest parties use their rhetorical resources differently when communicating similar messages about gang violence, one of the most pressing and polarised issues in Swedish politics, on text-based and video-based social media. This is by using rhetorical criticism and constitutive rhetoric to compare how the political leaders strategically craft their messages differently across digital platforms. Through this, the study contributes to the research on digital political communication by understanding how political leaders use the situation with gang crime to strategically communicate their ideology in a way that connects with the audience and shapes political identity. The results of this study could show that nonverbal communication seems to support the speaker’s rhetorical ability to reinforce or change the message and build collective identity. More frequently, this was enabled in videos than in tweets. These findings are in line with Kjeldsen and Gelang’s (2023) study, indicating that nonverbal communication may function argumentatively in political communication.